Psychodynamic Therapy vs. CBT: Which Is Right for You?
The short answer: CBT (cognitive behavioral therapy) focuses on changing the thoughts and behaviors that cause distress right now, using structured skills and practice. Psychodynamic therapy focuses on understanding why those thoughts, feelings, and patterns developed, so change goes deeper and lasts. Both are effective. CBT often suits people who want targeted skills for a specific symptom; psychodynamic therapy often suits people facing recurring patterns or wanting to understand themselves more deeply.
I'm David Rothman, a Licensed Professional Counselor (LPC) and psychodynamic therapist working online with adults and couples across Colorado. I also use skills-based methods, so I see the value of both. Here's how to tell which may fit you.
What is CBT?
Cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) is a structured, skills-based therapy that helps you identify unhelpful thoughts and behaviors and replace them with more balanced ones. It was developed by psychiatrist Aaron Beck in the 1960s and is one of the most widely studied therapies.
CBT is built on the idea that thoughts, feelings, and behaviors influence each other. Change one, and the others shift too. In CBT you might:
- Track anxious or negative thoughts and test how accurate they are
- Learn coping skills for panic, worry, or low mood
- Gradually face situations you've been avoiding
- Complete worksheets or practice exercises between sessions
CBT is usually present-focused and time-limited, often lasting a set number of sessions.
What is psychodynamic therapy?
Psychodynamic therapy is a talk therapy that explores how past experiences, inner conflicts, and unconscious patterns shape how you feel and relate to others today. Rather than following a set structure, sessions are open conversations where you bring whatever feels most important.
In psychodynamic therapy you might:
- Explore feelings you've learned to avoid or push away
- Notice patterns that repeat across relationships and situations
- Connect present struggles to earlier experiences
- Use the therapy relationship itself to understand how you relate to others
For a fuller explanation, see my guide, Psychodynamic Therapy Online in Colorado.
Psychodynamic therapy vs. CBT: side by side
The simplest way to put it: CBT asks what you're thinking and how to change it; psychodynamic therapy asks why you feel and act the way you do.
CBT
Psychodynamic therapy
Main question
What thoughts and behaviors need to change?
Why do these patterns exist?
Focus
Present symptoms
Underlying patterns, emotions, relationships
Session style
Structured, with an agenda
Open, exploratory conversation
Therapist role
Coach and teacher
Collaborator and close observer
Between sessions
Homework and worksheets
Reflection and noticing
Typical length
Often short-term, set number of sessions
Months to longer-term
Role of the past
Limited
Important, as it shapes the present
Therapy relationship
Supportive context
An active part of the work
Often best for
Specific symptoms, targeted skills
Recurring patterns, relationships, deeper change
Which is more effective, CBT or psychodynamic therapy?
Both are effective, evidence-based treatments for common concerns like depression and anxiety. CBT has the larger body of research, partly because its structured format is easier to study. Research reviews of psychodynamic therapy show comparable results, and a widely cited 2010 review by Jonathan Shedler in American Psychologist found that its benefits tend to last and often keep growing after therapy ends.
Research also consistently shows that the quality of the relationship between client and therapist is one of the strongest predictors of success, whatever the approach. Finding a therapist you trust matters as much as choosing the method.
Which therapy is right for me?
The right choice depends on what you're looking for. These are general guidelines, not rules.
CBT may be a good fit if you:
- Want practical tools for a specific problem, like panic attacks or insomnia
- Prefer structure, clear goals, and homework
- Are looking for shorter-term treatment
Psychodynamic therapy may be a good fit if you:
- Notice the same patterns repeating in relationships or life
- Feel stuck despite understanding what you "should" do
- Tried skills-based therapy and want to go deeper
- Want to understand yourself, not only manage symptoms
- Are working through relationship issues or the effects of trauma
Can you combine CBT and psychodynamic therapy?
Yes, and many therapists do. In my own work, I use psychodynamic therapy as the foundation for lasting change, and I bring in concrete skills when a client needs relief right away, such as managing anxiety before a stressful event. Understanding why a pattern exists and having tools to handle it in the moment work well together.
If you often find yourself asking, "Why do I keep doing this?", my article Why Do I Keep Repeating the Same Relationship Patterns? explores that question further.
Frequently asked questions
Is psychodynamic therapy better than CBT? Neither is better overall. Both are effective; the best fit depends on your goals, your preferences, and the therapist you work with.
Is CBT faster than psychodynamic therapy? CBT is often shorter-term. Psychodynamic therapy can also be brief, but it is often longer because it aims for deeper, lasting change.
Which is better for anxiety? Both help. CBT offers direct tools for managing anxious thoughts and panic. Psychodynamic therapy explores what's driving the anxiety, which can help when it keeps returning.
Which is better for depression? Both are effective for depression. Psychodynamic therapy can be especially helpful when depression is tied to harsh self-criticism, loss, or relationship patterns.
I tried CBT and it didn't help. Should I try psychodynamic therapy? It may be worth it. Many people who found CBT helpful in the short term, or who felt it didn't reach the root of their struggles, benefit from a deeper approach.
Can I do either one online? Yes. Both CBT and psychodynamic therapy work well by secure video.
About the author
David Rothman, M.A., LPC is a psychodynamic psychotherapist offering online therapy to adults and couples throughout Colorado. He specializes in anxiety, depression, couples therapy, and trauma, and his work is informed by the writing of Nancy McWilliams along with skills-based methods. He is a Licensed Professional Counselor in Colorado (LPC.0023119) and Nevada (CP6305-R).
Availability: My practice is currently full and not accepting new clients. [Add waitlist or referral details here.]
Learn more at davidrothmantherapy.com.
This article is for general education and is not a substitute for professional care. If you are in crisis, call or text 988 (Suicide & Crisis Lifeline) or call 911.